At the table
Disadvantage on every attack against you is one of the strongest defenses in the game. Against a single big attacker it is often better than a large AC bonus, because it applies to every roll, every round.
The cloak has a rhythm. The first hit each round is at disadvantage; once something lands, the illusion flickers off and the rest of that round’s attacks come in normally. That makes it best against enemies with one big attack and weaker against swarms of small ones.
When to hand it out
Mid levels, to the character who has to stand in harm’s way: a melee rogue, a paladin or a front-line cleric. It also suits a caster who keeps getting focused by archers.
Pairs well with
- High AC. Disadvantage and a big AC multiply, and the character becomes very hard to hit.
- Shield. A reaction that catches the attacks that roll well anyway.
- Healers who keep it running. Damage turns it off, so avoiding that first hit matters.