At the table
The Oathbow is a weapon that wants a story. Its elvish whisper and its spoken vow make every big fight personal: the archer names the enemy, and from then on every arrow at that target has advantage and deals an extra 3d6. Against a boss, that is a staggering amount of damage.
The drawback is part of the drama. Until the sworn enemy dies, every other weapon has disadvantage, so the archer is committed. Swearing an oath against a creature that escapes can leave a character hobbled for a week.
When to hand it out
Mid to high levels, to a dedicated archer. It fits a campaign with a recurring villain the party wants to hunt down, because the oath then has a target that matters.
Pairs well with
- Archer builds. Sharpshooting fighters and rangers get the most from the extra damage.
- Winged Boots. Height and range keep the archer safe while the oath does its work.
- A named nemesis. The bow is at its best when the oath means something to the character.